Choose wisely ...
Choosing a place to train can be a difficult choice for those who are unfamiliar with the martial arts landscape. Many people, having little else to go on, make a choice perhaps based on price - or even worse - the rank the instructor is wearing around his waist. Choosing on price is akin to buying a car - there are cheap cars and there are expensive cars - generally, you get what you pay for. Don't expect to be driving off in a mercedes if you are only prepared to pay a KIA price. And making a decision based on rank is usually not the best way to go either - mainly because rank means so very little in today's martial arts world; people are awarding themselves ranks, that are not commensurate with their ability - and certainly the ranks has almost nothing to do with 'teaching skill'. So how does the novice proceed?In my view, an instructor must embody the concept of excellence. He or she must be excellent at what they do and be excellent in their ability to inspire and guide others toward that same level of excellence (if not surpass it). Further, in my view, an instructor must live congruently – that is, they should display excellence in other areas of their lives as well; not just in their chosen art. Many will disagree with this; but I think it is what really separates the ‘men’ from the ‘boys’. In short, an instructor is a leader; and a big part of real leadership is to be able to inspire others to ‘rise above’ and achieve the ‘extraordinary’. If an instructor cannot ‘rise above’ himself (or herself), in all aspect of their lives, then they are falling short in their understanding of what it means to be a leader. JBW
Comments
What some schools forget is that people are smart. People see thru shiney marketing if it has no leg to stand on.
You did hit it on the head when you said that sending students away is not a common practice, when indeed it should be. Wouldn't it be fantastic to, in say 10 yrs from now, read an interview with a champion in an art you don't practice say: "Well, funny story, I went to the wrong school at first but this lovely instructor gave me directions to a different school that offered what I wanted and here I'm national champion!"